For an executive pastor search

I've run the operation without the title

Staff, systems, budget, and board in a church of 550–650 after twenty years running $20M+ portfolios and teams of up to ten.

Andy Stahlbusch
550–650
Congregation served
4
Church staff supervised
$20M+
Portfolios led before ministry

You need someone who can hold the staff, the systems, and the money without carrying it all on his own, and who won’t treat the operational side as a consolation prize. I functioned as the church’s operational leader even though there was no formal Executive Pastor role, and I spent two decades before that doing the same kind of work in a different sector.

Three operational projects

The situation I inherited, what I built, and what changed. Written the way I would brief a board.

Team members taking notes around a meeting table
Systems · 2025

Putting a church on a real system of record

Ministry management ran on spreadsheets, memory, and one person’s inbox. I evaluated the options, selected BreezeChMS, migrated the church onto it, and trained the staff to run care tracking, group registration, online giving, and attendance in one place.

Now the church’s system of record for care, groups, and attendance

Staff praying together around a table of open Bibles
Staff · 2024–2026

Every ministry area, one staff report

Children’s, Youth, Young Adults, groups, and adult discipleship all reported into me, along with communications and care. I supervised the Youth Pastor and staff directly, set the rhythm of one-on-ones, and built the volunteer structures each area needed to run without me in the room.

Direct supervision of staff and church-wide volunteer teams

Conference room with a long wooden table
Money · 2024–2026

Benevolence with the trustee board

Benevolence sits where compassion and a fixed budget collide. I worked with the trustee board on requests, advocated for families inside real constraints, and pushed for criteria written down in advance so that decisions were consistent instead of personal.

Criteria documented so decisions survive a change of staff

What I’d look at first

I haven’t seen your church, so these are questions, not proposed changes. They're what I'd ask about before proposing anything.

  • 01Where does the senior pastor’s week actually go, and which parts of it shouldn’t be his?
  • 02What does the staff think is broken that nobody’s written down?
  • 03Which systems hold the church’s data, and who can actually get a report out of them?
  • 04How are benevolence and discretionary spending decided, and is that written anywhere?
  • 05Which volunteer roles are held by one irreplaceable person?

He took the operational weight off the rest of us, and he did it without making it about himself.

A colleague on staff

I preach, but that isn’t the job I’m applying for

An executive role isn’t necessarily a teaching role, and I’m not pitching for the pulpit. I preach when asked, I’ve taught classes church-wide, and one message will tell you more than a line on my résumé can.

Ask for the executive resume

References with names and titles, the full executive resume, and my long-form doctrinal answers are one email away.

Email address copied